Rebuilding the rollover (separate message) fixed that problem, so I thought perhaps rebuilding this page might solve this one. Not a pretty thought, possibly having to rebuild everything in my site.
Anyway…
That changed nothing. A freshly built page demonstrates the same disregard for the set preferences: what should be normal link text in light green is black with a light underline. Active is ignored, visited is ignored. These are basic links, no special styles.
Looking at the page in layout it looks OK, but it is as described in any preview.
Removed the Not In Frameset Redirect action, just in case. No Difference.
.Caption10 { color:#000; font-family:Verdana,Arial,Helvetica,sans-serif; font-size:10px All Seasons Motel
So your links are primarily styled “Caption10” which has a colour value of 000 - which is Black
Why not create a style for your links in the bottom 4 boxes in the inspector links section using styles that you have created for use elsewhere on your pages (not just the top 3 where you have just chosen colours)
Create new styles in the styles inspector for link, visited, hover and active with the attributes that you want. Save them as permanent styles with appropriate names eg .Link, .LinkHover, .LinkVisited etc then select them in the bottom 4 sections of the Link part of the Page Appearance selector.